How to Handle Tenant Disputes Without Lawyers

By PropsManager Team | Dec 17, 2025

How to Handle Tenant Disputes Without Lawyers

1. Listen First

Often, tenants just want to be heard. Let them vent. "I understand why you are upset."

2. Refer to the Lease

"I know you want to get a cat, but the lease we both signed states 'No Pets.' I have to enforce the rules fairly for everyone."

3. Find a Middle Ground

"I can't waive the late fee entirely, but since this is your first time, I will reduce it by 50% if you pay today."

4. Cash for Keys

If the relationship is broken, offer them an out. "If you move out by Friday and leave the place clean, I will give you $500 and not file for eviction." It's cheaper than a 3-month court battle.

Conclusion

Be firm but fair. Most disputes can be solved with a conversation.